Blog EntryMy Liberal RantsJun 18, '08 3:50 AM
for everyone
There are many things that i wanted to see change, therefore i claim to remain an activist, even if no longer as by definition of the status quo left. Having been gone and back gave me the capacity to look introspectively on what makes us tick and not tick as a people. The level of our conservativeness utterly disgusts me as it hampers the growth of our nation. The Philippines is indeed one conservative hell hole, that is, foremost religiously conservative which seeps and interferes government decision making, overruling state policy and hijacking culture. Take for instance 5 issues that government has an awfully backward stance due to Catholic dogma/Christian monopoly on our culture - Abortion, Population Control, LGBT rights, Divorce and the Separation of Religion and State.

Among the five, I strongly believe that Population Control should be a top priority of the state. It's even outrageous to think that many activist of the left of center belie the urgency of overpopulation. What's more dumber to hear are the catholic and other christian fundamentalists quoting the bible, that god allegedly instructed man to populate the earth without limit...err something to that effect, hence control is against their moral bedrock, overriding reason and elementary mathematics of the malthusian limit. Immigration (or diaspora), Urban decay, Water Crisis, Food Crisis, Poor School Facilities and many other conditions of our pathetic third world are directly and indirectly testaments to the unabated growth of our population as it outpaces the actual capacity of society in producing goods and creating services. Yet looking introspectively is something Filipinos almost always never do, as we see problems exist externally and with that our tenacity to fault someone or something else. Inversely proportional to that is also our collective denial of individual accountability to the bigger picture. For example,  the current rice crisis in our country is due to many factors beyond the control of the individual. And yes true, such as government's irresponsibility and lack of foresight. However still, hypothetically a construction worker earns minimum wage (at Php5,000) and has 10 children to feed with a wife who washes clothes in daytime. The construction site's engineer on the other hand earns quadruple that and only has 2 children with a wife who probably works as a clerk. This disparity is undeniable existing yet we fail to see this as one of of the crux to our woes.

The other thing worthy of note is the state of Women's Rights and feminist attitude in our country. I can say that it is relatively more progressive compared to many Islamic countries and or Latin American countries even if machismo and male bravado is still the rule of thumb. But then again, because of our tight catholic upbringing and the "sanctity of life", our society has deprived women from their reproductive rights, specifically the right to Abortion and Divorce. Although I do believe that it should be strictly regulated and highly restricted to cases such as rape and or endangerment of a woman's life, the bottom line is that we have a long way to go in emancipating our attitudes with regards to women's rights.

The Catholic Church in the Philippines remains a reactionary and backward force to reckon with. The absence of Divorce and Gay Rights in this country also reflects the entertwining of  church and state. And unless the state can completely secularize herself and liberalize culture, we are basically choosing to be poor rather than immoral in the eyes of the pope.

mariacacao wrote on Jun 18
I agree with you on some points arsi. There are sections in society that remain conservative on issues like divorce, gay rights, etc.

While the issue of 'population control' has been a central theme of many debates at present, I think there are some dangerous assumptions that lie beneath the statements that you made. It is not merely a case of 'overpopulation' and scarce resources. That Malthusian logic has long been debunked by social scientists around the world. The issue goes way beyond that. In the Philippines, even if you hypothetically implement a five-year moratorium on pregnancies resources still won't be enough because the distribution of wealth remain only among those at the top. The liberal "trickle down" effect is an assumption that does not hold water in reality.

I agree with you that 'reactionary' sectors do hamper efforts to curb the current rate of population growth. But will the issue of scarcity, poverty, food crisis and all those things you mentioned above be addressed by merely giving out free condoms, having sex education and the like? A change of mindset about contraceptives and reproductive health is one thing (which I am supportive of), but the problems you pointed out do run deeper. Population growth does indeed aggravate the experience of poverty, but it does not, my dear, cause it.

That's my two cents worth. :-)

Thanks for the interesting post.
arsikoi wrote on Jun 18, edited on Jun 18
I agree. I don't think there's much contradiction with your outlook. I read the magazine published by the health sector and I couldn't agree more with the analysis such as land use conversion, unequal distribution of land, lack of government support, et. al. as reasons to why there's shortage of cheap rice in the Philippines. On the other hand, i do believe that there's science behind Malthusianism (such as the case of easter island's civilization collapse). In fact, conservationists and environmentalists site malthusian limit as base principles. This is of course, another debate on another day.

I also agree that social class relations still is the major cause of poverty in our country, but let me gather 10 of my non-political friends and ask them what they think of these things i mention above, I won't be surprised if an overwhelming majority embrace backward notions, especially when it comes to population control. Changing mindset and social attitudes is complimentary to political movements that criticizes big government.

Population control is not the panacea of our country's woes, but it can't either be achieved purely by urging Government to dole out free condoms. These are just band aide solutions, the bigger fish to fry is ousting church influence out of people's lives and in government. That starts with people like you and me talking. That reminds me, someone always yells to me about "accountability shit"... heheheh, i guess that's what i'm asking our people: introspective accountability.
Add a Comment
   
© 2008 Multiply, Inc.    About · Blog · Terms · Privacy · Corp Info · Contact Us · Help